Are you a Linux desktop user who loves Ubuntu but is wary of Unity? You're in luck. There are lots of Ubuntu spins, both from Canonical and independent developers, which preserve the basic infrastructure and essence of Ubuntu but replace the default Unity desktop.
Canonical has been producing official spins since its second release, but they have been getting more attention since Ubuntu switched to Unity. The oldest, and one of the most popular, is Kubuntu, which offers the KDE desktop; if you want Ubuntu goodness on an underpowered computer, there's the lightweight Lubuntu; and starting with the 13.04 Raring Ringtail release, users will also be able to use the Gnome desktop thanks to the new Ubuntu Gnome spin.
As well as these official spins, many independent developers use Ubuntu as the base for their own distros. While most of these are just the stock Ubuntu release with a few added applications, some developers put in the extra effort.
Bodhi Linux is a semi-rolling distro that's based on the stable Ubuntu Long Term Support (LTS) releases. It installs an elegant-looking, minimal system that can be customised easily to suit a regular desktop or a dated machine. Also featured is Zorin OS, designed to appease users moving from Windows.
How we tested...
Comparing the distros was tricky. As they're all underpinned by Ubuntu, the usual parameters for comparison, such as installation, were very similar. The main reason for this roundup is to help you select a distro that gives you a better desktop experience than Unity.
Another important point of comparison is system requirements. Unity requires accelerated graphics, which makes the sta ndard Ubuntu unsuitable for older computers. We also paid attention to the custom tools shipped with some distros that have their own package manager. Some replace the default tools with their particular desktop environment to increase usability.
No distro comparison is complete without a look at bundled apps and configuration options, and even more so, since both of these factors depend on the desktop environment.
Default apps
For most distros in this roundup, the choice of default software depends on the desktop. So you'll find Gnome-apps such as Evolution, Shotwell, Rhythmbox and Totem in Ubuntu Gnome, and KDE-apps such as Kmail, Amarok and Dragon Player in Kubuntu.
Although both of these distros try to remain true to their desktops, there are some exceptions. Most notable is LibreOffice, the default suite in Ubuntu Gnome, Kubuntu and Zorin. The lightweight Lubuntu uses AbiWord and Gnumeric instead, and Bodhi ships with only a basic text editor. In fact, the only real app in Bodhi is the Midori web browser, which you can use to access Bodhi's online app store and download new apps. Interestingly, Google Docs thinks of Midori as an outdated version of Google Chrome.
Zorin ships with the real proprietary Google Chrome, while Lubuntu includes its open source sister, Chromium. Instead of Gnome's Epiphany browser (now rechristened simply Web), Ubuntu Gnome includes Firefox. Kubuntu ships with its own Reconq browser, although it does have a shortcut to install Firefox.
In stark contrast to Bodhi, the other lightweight distro, Lubuntu is chock full of apps. It's got some GTK apps such as the document viewer Evince, Archive Manager and image editor mtPaint, along with feature-weight apps that go with its LXDE desktop, such as the Leafpad text editor and PCManFM. L ubuntu also has the Sylpheed email client and the Chromium web browser. It's also got Audacious and Gnome Mplayer so you can play most popular formats: MP3s, AVIs and MP4s etc.
Ubuntu Gnome also lets you play MP3s out of the box with Rhythmbox. You won't find any plugins under Kubuntu but its multimedia apps are designed to fetch codecs as and when they are needed. The best thing about the Ubuntu derivatives is that you can install proprietary plugins and codecs to play restricted formats while installing the distro.
Zorin is the only distro in this roundup that lets you view content in proprietary formats from within the live environment. At 1.5GB, Zorin is the heaviest distro. Besides the apps already mentioned, it includes Gimp, Shotwell, Google Chrome, Gwibber, Thunderbird, Empathy, Totem, Rhythmbox, VLC and even the OpenShot video editor. It also includes Wine to install Windows-only apps.
Unless you are using Zorin, you'll need to pay a visit to th e distro's package management app soon after installing. In Bodhi, it's the first thing you'll need to do, while Lubuntu, Ubuntu Gnome and Kubuntu can give you a fair amount of mileage with their default selection.
Verdict
Ubuntu Gnome - 3/5
Kubuntu - 3/5
Lubuntu - 4/5
Bodhi Linux - 1/5
Zorin - 5/5
Intended purpose
The distros we've chosen provide a different GUI to Unity, but they each ensure the distro works well for its intended audience.
The aim of the Ubuntu Gnome spin is to provide a relatively pure Gnome desktop. Since the main Ubuntu distro still uses libraries from Gnome 3.6, Ubuntu Gnome 13.04 ships with an older Gnome release, and users will have to manually install the latest Gnome from the Person Package A rchive (PPA). Users will also miss out on new Gnome apps, such as Boxes and Web, which depend on libraries from the latest release.
Kubuntu does for KDE what Ubuntu Gnome does for Gnome Shell. But Kubuntu nicely integrates the KDE desktop. That said, it doesn't include all apps developed by the KDE project, most notably the Calligra Office Suite.
The Lubuntu developers wanted to create a less resource-hungry distro and LXDE fits the bill. Lubuntu also includes software like Mplayer, which makes it more usable than its peers.
Bodhi Linux is also a lightweight distro, but encourage users to customise the system, handled nicely by its package management system.
Lastly, Zorin OS is designed for Windows users, and pulls this off brilliantly thanks to its default interface and the custom Look Changer app.
Verdict
Ubuntu Gnome - 2/5
Kubuntu - 4/5
Lubuntu - 5/5
Bodhi Linux - 5/5
Zorin - 5/5< br />
Desktop Experience
Before Unity, Ubuntu was the most popular Linux distro for desktop users - and for good reason. It has the best-in-class Ubiquity distro installer, as well as an easy-to-use package management system that allows users to upgrade with a single click. All distros in this roundup share the same lineage. While some need more resources to run comfortably, what sets them apart from Ubuntu and each other is how they look, and how you operate them. This is also the main reason why you would want to use an Ubuntu derivative instead of the real thing.
The questions were asking are: do the spins appeal to new Linux users coming in from other OSes, such as Windows and Mac OS? And if you're an existing Linux user, who had Ubuntu in the past, which spin returns to the pre-Unity days?
Ubuntu Gnome - 2/5
If you were disappointed by Unity, then the desktop environment Ubuntu Gnome offers is unlikely to make you happy either. There are a number of similarities between Gnome 3 and Unity, although they each go about implementing them differently. If you dislike Unity's vertical launcher, you probably won't be that keen on the similar launcher in Gnome. And while the launcher in Unity is always visible, in Gnome you have to bring up the Activities View before you can even see it.
Gnome's other low points are minimal window furniture and the inability to create desktop icons, which make it a distro that's only likely to please existing Gnome users. In fact, even existing Gnome users won't like this spin, because it ships with the older Gnome 3.6.
Kubuntu - 3/5
At first glance KDE looks very much like Windows: it's got a Taskbar-like panel at the bottom of the screen, a launch menu in the corner, quicklaunch icons, and a notification area with tray icons. But to pitch KDE to new users as simply 'looking like Windows' is doing the desktop environment a disservice.
Its real power lies in the vast configuration options and features like Activities, which, sadly, users will find confusing or, at worst, totally ignore. Activities are, in fact, custom workspaces or virtual desktops that you can setup and switch between for a given activity, for example a desktop ready with all the apps open for some web development. Kubuntu is the oldest Ubuntu spin, it has an active community of users and it's the go-to distro for users burnt by Unity, but it's missing some of Ubuntu's best features, such as the Software Center.
Lubuntu - 3/5
Like KDE, Lubuntu's LXDE desktop is similar to Windows, with a panel at the bottom. The menu, though, is reminiscent of Windows 98. When you think about it, a Windows 98 look-a-like won't really lure Windows 7/XP users, especially when you consider the fact that LX DE doesn't have other Windows features, such as live thumbnail previews.
Additionally, Lubuntu lacks Ubuntu One, and integration with PCManFM and Sylpheed is still on the developers' to-do list. But then Lubuntu is aimed at a different set of users: those who want to run an Ubuntu-like desktop on an old, underpowered machine. This is something Lubuntu does remarkably well.
The fact it also supplies a pleasant desktop environment is an added bonus.
Bodhi Linux - 2/5
Another minimalist distro, Bodhi Linux is based on the elegant Enlightenment Window Manager and has its own file manager, several gadgets and compositing effects. With Bodhi you can bring an old machine back to life in style.
The distro also offers several different desktop layout styles: Desktop is a traditional layout with a menu, Taskbar and System Tray at the bottom; Laptop/Netbook puts the System Tray, menu and Taskbar on the top, along with some gadgets, and moves the appl ication launcher to the bottom; while Fancy places the application launcher on the left of the screen. There's also a style for small/touchscreen devices, which uses an application menu like Unity's Dash or Gnome 3's Activities.
Zorin OS - 5/5
This is hands-down the best distro, offering the ultimate desktop experience for existing Linux users, as well as those coming from other operating systems. Not only is the default Zorin desktop styled to resemble Windows 7, for added familiarity, its custom application launcher also mimics the Windows 7 Start menu. Existing Linux users can use the Zorin Look Changer app to make the desktop act and look like Gnome 2.
If you can spare €10, you can download the Ultimate edition, which has additional Mac OS X and Windows 2000 styles. Zorin also includes all of the Ubuntu goodies, such as Ubuntu One, which is well integrated into the distro. It also instills good desktop practices by regularly reminding users to set up the backup app.
System requirements
Due to the different system requirements of their desktop environments, some of the spins might not run on all kinds of hardware. The most demanding distro in our roundup is Ubuntu Gnome thanks to the desktop's insistence on using accelerated graphics. On the other hand, you can run KDE, and therefore Kubuntu, on a computer that doesn't have a discrete graphics card installed. The desktop will, instead, default to having only the most basic compositing effects, but it will remain fully functional.
If you need a distro for an older box, neither Ubuntu Gnome nor Kubuntu will work as well as Lubuntu or Bodhi Linux. To productively use the LXDE-based Lubuntu you'll need at least 512MB of RAM. The project also produces special installation ISOs for computers with less than 700MB RAM.
Bodhi Linux goes down even further. You can install it on a system with 128MB of RAM and it only takes up 2.5GB of hard disk space. The good thing about Bodhi is that it can scale up just as easily on a more recent, well-endowed machine. Just use its package manager to fetch the application suite of full-featured software instead of the lighter-weight packages.
Zorin OS gives you the best of both worlds. While the normal version is based on Gnome and requires the same amount of resources as Kubuntu, there's also a LXDE-based Lite edition for older computers.
Verdict
Ubuntu Gnome - 1/5
Kubuntu - 3/5
Lubuntu - 4/5
Bodhi Linux - 5/5
Zorin - 4/5
Documentation and support
One of the reasons Ubuntu is so popular is the support infrastructure and its active community of users. But how do the derivatives fair? Ubuntu Gnome has a growing community with its own IRC channel and a mailing list, and while it doesn't have forum boards it regularly dispenses help to users on its official Google+ Community page.
The oldest Ubuntu spin, Kubuntu, has a very active community that hosts KDE-specific forums, mailing lists and an IRC channel. The distro also has information on getting help in languages other than English, and there's a comprehensive ebook guide available on ubuntuguide.org.
Lubuntu hosts its documentation and support on Ubuntu infrastructure. There's documentation about the various applications and how to set up different components. The link to the forums shows all posts with the tag 'lubuntu' on ubuntuforums.org. You can interact with Lubuntu developers on its mailing lists and IRC.
Zorin OS has a very rudimentary installation guide, though they have forum boards with a tutorial section. Shelling out €5 will get you premium technical support for three issues.
Bodhi Linux has the most organised suppo rt and documentation. There's a quick start guide, and detailed guides on Enlightenment and customising Bodhi. It's forum boards even dispense advice on ARM-powered devices.
Verdict
Ubuntu Gnome - 2/5
Kubuntu - 3/5
Lubuntu - 2/5
Bodhi Linux - 5/5
Zorin - 2/5
Custom Tools
As we've already said, what sets our contenders apart from the myriad of Ubuntu-based distros is the developer effort that's gone into fitting the distro to its user base.
Consider Zorin, for example. It's designed specifically for Windows users who want easy and smooth access to Linux, so it includes a custom Look Changer application that lets you change the interface at the touch of a button. In the freely downloadable edition of the OS, the application offers a choice of Windows 7, XP or Gnome 2. Donate €10 for the Ultimate edition and you also get support for Mac OS X, Unity and Windows 2000. Zorin's Web Browser Manager makes it easy to install different browsers and the distro also includes a redesigned Ubuntu Software Center.
Bodhi Linux is all about custom tools. It ships with the Eccess System Tool for basic system administration tasks, such as managing users and time. There's a board on the Bodhi Linux forum dedicated to custom apps written in Elementary and Python that are available in the official repositories. Another highlight is its online App Center, which makes installing apps easier by grouping them into software bundles and creating custom packages of similar tools. For example, if you want to install a selection of different educational apps, you can install the Educational Pack, which includes TuxPaint, TuxTyping, Gcompris etc.
The developers of Lubuntu dealt with package management by creating a lightweight version of Ubuntu Software Center called - you guessed it! - Lubuntu Software Center. This arranges software in different categories, you mark apps that you want to install, add them to the apps basket and install them all in one go. The tool also has an Expert mode for installing individual libraries.
Kubuntu also includes its own package manager, Moun, and the HomeRun launcher, which runs full screen and is similar to Unity's Dash and Gnome's Activities.
The one spin that doesn't have any custom tools is Ubuntu Gnome. The distro includes the stock Ubuntu Software Center and is, in fact, missing some Gnome tools like the web browser and the Boxes virtualisation app. This is further confused by the fact that the distro includes two User Accounts apps, one from Gnome and from Ubuntu.
Verdict
Ubuntu Gnome - 1/5
Kubuntu - 2/5
Lubuntu - 3/5
Bodhi Linux - 5/5
Zorin - 5/5
Most distros delegate the task of customising the desktop to the GUI. This is quite a disadvantage for Ubuntu Gnome as its default customisation settings will work for the average user but the more advanced Linux user will need to get additional tools to tweak their desktops. On the other end of the spectrum is KDE and its endless configuration options, which can be overwhelming.
Lubuntu also has lots of configuration options. There's an Openbox configuration manager and a customiser from the LXDE project. There are also different apps for modifying keyboard, mouse, monitor and power management etc.
Kubuntu, in contrast, doesn't have its own set of configuration tools like OpenSUSE's Yast or Mageia's Control Center.
Bodhi Linux lets users select a theme and a wallpaper to cha nge the desktop layout. You can also load different desktop gadgets, such as battery and clock. There's a settings panel which you can use to change the wallpaper and theme of the desktop and apps, as well as adjust the number of virtual desktops, customise the menu, launchers, file manager, setup power management and so on.
Zorin is the only distro here that ships with the Ubuntu Tweak tool, and also uses the Ufw firewall app that can be configured with the gufw front-end.
Verdict
Ubuntu Gnome - 2/5
Kubuntu - 4/5
Lubuntu - 4/5
Bodhi Linux - 4/5
Zorin - 4/5
The verdict
All the distros in this roundup use a different desktop environment and some even target a totally different user base. Logically then, If you're a KDE user y ou should be using Kubuntu; if you want a distro for the old machine gathering dust in the attic, pick Lubuntu.
Unfortunately the same logic doesn't apply to Ubuntu Gnome. The current release of the distro (13.04) is handicapped by the fact that its parent still uses the older Gnome 3.6 release, forcing it to do the same. While this might not stop fans of Gnome and Ubuntu manually pulling the latest Gnome desktop from the PPA, we can't recommend the stock distro to inexperienced Linux users.
A stock Bodhi Linux release also necessitates a visit to the package manager, but the distro's online app store and its package management system makes the process really simple and straightforward. Plus Bodhi lets users select from several desktop layouts and thanks to the distro's minimal hardware requirements you can run it on virtually any computer.
A view to a kill
The winner of the roundup and by a comfortable margin is Zorin OS (named after the Bond v illain Max Zorin). The distro successfully uses its Ubuntu core to create a ready-to-use Linux desktop that will also appeal to users coming from different operating systems.
While the default look of the Zorin desktop mimics Windows 7, fans of Gnome 2 can change the desktop to appear and function like their favourite desktop, with a single click.
The distro is packed with applications for the average desktop user and as well as the freely available Core edition, the distro produces several premium editions (starting at €7) tailored for particular use. For example, the Business edition has tools for accounting, book-keeping, stock analysis etc.
Other premium editions include Gaming, Multimedia and an Ultimate edition that contains - as you might expect - all the tools included in the other editions.
Final scores
Ubuntu Gnome - 1/5
Xubuntu - 4/5
Lubuntu - 3/5
Bodhi Linux - 4/5
Zorin - 5/5
     |
No comments:
Post a Comment